Friday 7 December 2012

Scales of Measure

I want to share with you the following, in order to demonstrate that focusing upon weight and being a slave to the scales is definitely not the best indicator in determining the health of your body!

In January of this year I returned to MMU to complete the final two modules of my MSc, one of which was based upon body composition.  This literally means what it says, what the body is composed of, i.e. fat mass and fat free mass; fat mass is the amount of fat in the body and fat free mass is everything else, i.e. water, protein (muscle) & mineral (bone).  We were extremely fortunate to have access to a range of body composition measuring tools, one of which has the amazing title of “air displacement plethysmography”, more familiarly known as the Bod Pod; a very expensive and state-of-the-art piece of kit that measures changes in air volume and pressure to determine the fat mass and fat free mass of the lycra clad individual inside!
 
Cross-sectional view of the Bod Pod
 
I decided to base my research for this module upon how a personal commitment to a meticulous nutrition & exercise discipline would enable me to improve my physique and reduce my total fat mass; after all, if you’re going to advise others to make lifestyle changes, you must first be prepared to do so yourself! 

My first measurements undertaken in the bod pod on the 1st of February 2012 revealed the following:-


Weight

74.5 kg

Body Mass Index (BMI)

23 (normal 20-25)

Waist Circumference

79 cm

Fat Mass

19.9%

Bod Pod Rating

Lean

Obviously I was very pleased with these results, but I wanted to see if I could improve upon them and set myself a goal of approximately 7 weeks in which to do so.  However, things did not proceed as planned and the second module being undertaken was incredibly demanding and time-consuming, so much so that I was literally working on it day and night.  Dedicating every spare moment sat at the computer, in order to meet submission deadlines meant that I couldn’t possibly adhere to my proposed plan and although I didn’t adopt unhealthy eating patterns, I didn’t dedicate the time that I would normally to preparing my meals.   My running timetable decreased to just a couple of times per week and my attendance at the gym reduced by half and as such, my energy intake decreased as I obviously didn’t require the same amount of fuel if I wasn’t training.  The 7 seven weeks passed quickly and I returned to the lab on the 21st of March 2012 where a repeat of the same measurements revealed the following:- 


Weight

72.9 kg

Body Mass Index (BMI)

22 (normal 20-25)

Waist Circumference

83 cm

Fat Mass

22.9%

Bod Pod Rating

Moderately Lean

So, let’s take a closer look at this; due to my decreased energy intake my weight had reduced by 1.6 kg, reducing my BMI measurement accordingly; now if these were the only measurements you were using to assess your health, you would have good reason to think that this was beneficial.  However, as you can also see my waist circumference measurement, a good measure of central fat distribution and predictor of increased risk to health, had in-fact increased by 4 cm, taking it above the recommended 80 cm cut-off and my fat mass had increased by 3%, facilitating a reduction in my bod pod fitness rating. 
 
Central & abdominal adiposity - associated with the risk
of insulin resistance, the possibility of developing
type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease

This was definitely not the result I was hoping to achieve, but nevertheless the data is revealing in several ways; it demonstrates that physical exercise is essential in maintaining fat free mass, reveals how rapidly body composition can change and how ineffective focusing solely upon weight and BMI is in determining the risk of developing weight-associated diseases such as type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease. 

Clients often ask me how quickly they can expect to see positive results from adopting recommended changes - healthier eating patterns and carrying out some form of physical exercise and I think that they seldom believe me when I tell them just a matter of weeks; I think the results from this unintentional but nonetheless valuable reverse development, reveal this to be the truth!

 Cathy x 

No comments:

Post a Comment